Well, it looks like we are moving in a new direction. One player has moved to Orlando for the next 15 or so months and one player has decided they don't want to play any longer. So we are down to three and that makes for some very drastic changes to the story arcs/metaplot of a White Wolf style storytelling game. The remaining players and I are still getting together this evening to discuss what to do and how to proceed.
I'm going to do a one-shot zombie game with the players effectively playing themselves coming back from a camping trip and the zombie plague/virus/attack has occurred during their trip. I'm either going to use the generic WoD rule set or FUDGE - depends on if I have time to throw together/find a decent character sheet.